Colin Jost Went Dumpster Diving in New York City for Scarlett Johansson’s Lost Engagement Ring—But There’s a Twist!

In a lighthearted moment shared during an episode of Pop Culture Jeopardy! on Amazon Prime Video, comedian Colin Jost recounted an amusing and somewhat absurd incident involving his wife, actress Scarlett Johansson. The story, which quickly went viral, revealed that Scarlett had once feared she had lost her precious engagement ring, leading Colin to take an extraordinary and somewhat desperate measure: dumpster diving across New York City.

The Lost Ring Saga

The engagement ring in question is no small item—it’s an 11-carat light brown diamond set on a black ceramic band, designed by Taffin de Givenchy, and valued at around $400,000, as detailed in Harper’s Bazaar from 2019. Given the ring’s size and value, Scarlett was understandably distressed when she thought she might have thrown it away by accident. In a moment of panic, she turned to Colin, who decided to take drastic action.

In an attempt to recover the lost item, Colin embarked on an unconventional journey, searching through 12 dumpsters scattered across New York City. His dedication to retrieving the ring, despite the increasingly grim prospects of success, adds a humorous and romantic twist to the story. However, in a comedic turn of events, Scarlett later revealed that the ring was not lost at all—it was actually sitting comfortably in her pocket all along.

Colin, with his signature humor, jokingly referred to the situation as “a great day for me,” as reported by Us Weekly on February 25, 2025. His recounting of the tale on Pop Culture Jeopardy! only added to the charm of the story, and the audience’s laughter further cemented the light-hearted nature of the mishap.

A Glimpse into Their Relationship

This quirky incident, widely covered in the media, highlights the playful dynamic between Colin and Scarlett, a couple known for their humor and mutual support. The two have been together since publicly announcing their relationship in 2017, getting engaged in 2019, and marrying in October 2020. They share a son, Cosmo, born in 2021, and Scarlett has a daughter, Rose, from a previous marriage. The duo has often showcased their easygoing rapport in public appearances, including a recent joint segment on the Today Show.

Their relationship, characterized by lighthearted moments and a deep sense of mutual respect, is a frequent topic of conversation in media outlets. Scarlett has expressed admiration for Colin in past interviews, calling him “a very, very, very great guy,” during a November 2024 appearance on Live with Kelly and Mark, as noted by EntertainmentNow on February 26, 2025. This public admiration reinforces the couple’s bond, making their personal anecdotes, such as the ring incident, all the more endearing.

Media Coverage and Public Reaction

The story quickly made its rounds across entertainment news platforms, with outlets like People, E! Online, and Hello! Magazine picking up the humorous tale. The widespread coverage painted Colin’s dumpster diving effort as a romantic gesture, albeit one that ultimately wasn’t necessary. The public’s reaction has largely embraced the light-hearted nature of the incident, with many praising Colin’s dedication to his wife, even if it meant rummaging through trash. Some outlets even viewed the episode as a testament to the couple’s strong relationship, seeing it as yet another example of how their shared humor and mutual affection strengthen their marriage.

The Endearing Humor Behind the Story

This charming anecdote reflects the playful, relatable side of celebrity relationships, reminding us that even the most glamorous of couples experience the same quirky mishaps as anyone else. Colin’s willingness to go to such lengths for his wife, despite the humorously fruitless effort, underscores his devotion to Scarlett. The couple’s ability to laugh off the situation together further highlights their bond, which, in many ways, is built on shared humor and support.

In the end, while Colin’s dumpster diving quest may have been a bit over the top, it provided a glimpse into the couple’s warm, loving relationship. And, as Scarlett revealed with a smile, sometimes the ring was right where you least expect it—right in your pocket.