The Dark Yet Heartwarming Reason Jenny McCarthy and Donnie Wahlberg Love Working Together!

When Jenny McCarthy and Donnie Wahlberg joined forces to produce and host Very Scary Lovers, a new true crime special for Investigation Discovery, the partnership quickly felt natural—almost like second nature. Premiering February 2, 2025, the one-hour program marks a rare professional collaboration for the married couple, and for McCarthy, the experience has been anything but ordinary. “Wherever I go with him, it feels like home,” she shared in recent interviews, describing the seamless dynamic of working alongside her husband.

A Tale of Love, Crime, and Collaboration

Very Scary Lovers is a dark dive into the infamous case of Benjamin and Erika Sifrit, the so-called “Thrill Killers” who were convicted for the 2002 murders of Joshua Ford and Martha Crutchley. The special explores the couple’s descent into violence—highlighting how a seemingly perfect marriage devolved into horror. Known for his role as host of Very Scary People, Wahlberg brings his seasoned expertise in true crime storytelling, while McCarthy, an avid true crime fan, offers a fresh perspective.

For the Wahlbergs, their personal connection added a unique layer to the production. “Having him next to me, I can dissect more out of him,” McCarthy explained, noting how she enjoyed delving into the psychology behind the crimes with Wahlberg’s guidance. “I love figuring out the psychology behind all of it.” Wahlberg, meanwhile, praised McCarthy’s intelligence and insight, calling her “a natural” at getting to the heart of the story.

Finding Comfort in the Unfamiliar

Though the subject matter is dark, McCarthy emphasized that the experience of working with her husband made it feel less like a job. “It totally doesn’t feel like we’re going to work,” she said. After 12 years together and more than a decade of marriage, the couple has developed a shorthand that allows them to seamlessly play to each other’s strengths. Wahlberg described it as “covering each other’s weaknesses,” adding that their collaboration on this project was a rare and exciting opportunity. “Despite the dark subject matter, we had a really good time making it together,” he said.

A Shared Vision for True Crime Storytelling

Produced under the couple’s new production banner, Work Baby, Very Scary Lovers represents more than just a one-off project—it’s a sign of the Wahlbergs’ commitment to blending personal passion with professional pursuits. While Wahlberg brings years of experience hosting true crime specials, McCarthy’s genuine curiosity and knack for digging into details adds a fresh angle. The duo’s chemistry and mutual respect are evident both on and off screen, making their partnership one to watch as they continue exploring new creative ventures together.

A Testament to Partnership

Ultimately, McCarthy’s comment about working with Wahlberg feeling “like home” speaks to more than just a comfort level—it reflects the deep bond the two have built over their years together. As they tackle true crime and dark subject matter, they do so with the support and trust that only a close partnership can provide. For fans of the genre, Very Scary Lovers offers not only a compelling story but also a behind-the-scenes glimpse of a couple who prove that sometimes the best collaborators are the ones closest to home.